Close to one in five people detained in the New Orleans jail are waiting for a court date (also known as adjudication) to resolve alleged probation or parole violations. This detention affects nearly 2,000 people a year and heavily inflates the local jail population. In this report, Vera conducted a thorough analysis of all probation and parole violation detentions in the year 2012, and concluded that pre-adjudication detention was overused in a high number of cases. Vera made the following recommendations to reduce the overuse of detention:

  • Implement administrative sanctions as an alternative to a lengthy court process and, generally, to detention;
  • Reduce initial use of detention by allowing more people to wait for their day in court in the community;
  • Review the detention status of alleged violators routinely;
  • Coordinate roles to develop common procedures for detention decision-making;
  • Improve the effectiveness of proceedings; and
  • Improve data collection and information sharing.

These evidence-based recommendations are a key opportunity for jurisdictions to rethink detention practices, safely reduce jail populations, and improve the lives of people under supervision.

Key Takeaway

We must look at who we are putting in our jails, how long we detain them, and whether they should be there in the first place. New Orleans is an example of how detention can be overused and unnecessary, and how policy changes that reduce detention of alleged violators of probation and parole can improve public safety and reduce harm for people under supervision.

Publication Highlights

  • Detaining probationers and parolees can greatly destabilize their lives—risking the loss of jobs, income, and housing—which hurts their chances of community success and increases their chances of recidivism.

  • While discretion is allowed, it is not often used: large numbers of people are detained with no consideration of their circumstances or the appropriateness of detention.

  • The majority of people who are detained for probation and parole violations do not go to prison after adjudication but are released and sent back to supervision.

Key Facts


City Jail Populations Are Falling, So Why Are Their Budgets Increasing?

Jail populations in big cities have declined nearly 30 percent in the last decade, fueled by a growing recognition of the brutal realities of jail. Its injustices are crystallized in the stories of people like Kalief Browder—who, at 16, spent three years in jail awaiting trial for allegedly stealing a backpack and died by suicide after his release. ...

Blog Post
  • Christian Henrichson
    Christian Henrichson
  • Nazish Dholakia
    Nazish Dholakia
March 25, 2021
Blog Post

Close the Atlanta City Detention Center and Deliver Long-term Public Safety

In September 2020, the City of Atlanta engaged the Vera Institute of Justice (Vera) to chart a path to close the Atlanta City Detention Center (ACDC). Vera met with key justice system stakeholders, service providers, and community advocates; analyzed data; and brought to bear evidence and examples from across the country to develop a strategy to re ...

  • Amy Cross, Elizabeth Swavola, Melvin Washington II, Sandhya Kajeepeta, Alex Boldin
March 01, 2021